Fuel should be injected as the finest of sprays - If this is not the case, not all the quantity of fuel that is injected will have time to burn fully, thus leaving sooty deposits: A certain level of sooty deposit is considered normal for a tfsi engine.
A difference in colour between the deposits on the injector, similarly to the colour of deposits on a spark plug, tend to indicate differences in the air/fuel ratio - lighter ones = more air - sooty ones, a higher ratio of fuel. The idea is to get the manufacturer's balance. Thus the lighter one seems to higher ratio of air / a lower ratio of fuel.
(At this stage, it would probably be wise to look at the state of the spark plugs in each cylinder - is the pattern of deposit on the outer ring and/or the ceramic insulator comparable with the state of the deposits on their respective injectors? I assume that the garage has inspected the plugs.)
A greater ratio of air would indicate that either (i) the other three (the sooty/black ones) are equally starved of air - which seems unlikely, or (ii) the lighter one is injecting less fuel - a fault in the injector caused by a restriction, lower pressure, and/or an air-leak.
You could cross your fingers and try a few doses of "injector cleaner"
Dirty injectors from a tsfi engine (not a TT): you will see that there isn't much difference in the colour of the deposit.
This problem seems inevitable on direct injection engines.